Divination isn’t scientific, but can it ever be therapeutic?

Divination isn’t scientific, but can it ever be therapeutic?

All In The Mind

Love it or hate it, there are reasons you might read your star sign and relate to what it says about you as a person. We all fall into cognitive traps — but if we’re aware of them, is it such a bad thing to indulge in your daily horoscope, or a tarot card reading? Today, we delve into the occult, to understand why some people seek messages from the universe, and if it can play a role in therapeutic care. If you want to hear more about otherworldly beliefs, check out our episode Spooky science: What's behind a paranormal experience? And Soul Search also has an episode called Astrology and tarot — telling the future, or connecting with the present? Guests: Professor Susan Krauss Whitbourne Professor Emerita of Psychological and Brain Sciences, University of Massachusetts Amherst Ryan Findlay Psychotherapist and tarot reader Credits: Presenter: Sana Qadar Reporter/producer: Shelby Traynor Senior producer: James Bullen Producer: Rose Kerr Sound engineer: Simon Branthwaite Extra information: When It Comes to Personality Tests, a Dose of Skepticism Is a Good Thing Why You Might Not Want to Trust a Personality Test – Psychology Today The validity of astrological predictions on marriage and divorce: a longitudinal analysis of Swedish register data Even the stars think that I am superior: Personality, intelligence and belief in astrology The Power of Rituals – Psychology Today

curiousskepticalthoughtfulreflectiveinformative

34:0426 Jul 2025

RSS Feed

Exploring Astrology: Therapy or Trap?

Episode Overview

  • Astrology's influence on personal identity despite lack of scientific backing.
  • Cognitive traps in astrology and occult practices.
  • Potential therapeutic benefits of tarot readings.
  • Historical and cultural significance of astrology.
  • Skepticism about astrology's scientific validity.
Tarot can bring something to sessions that he doesn't experience through traditional methods.

Astrology and tarot readings have long been subjects of intrigue and skepticism. Despite the lack of scientific backing, many find personal significance in their star signs and other divination practices. This podcast episode explores whether astrology can offer therapeutic benefits, or if it merely traps us in cognitive biases. Astrology, while not scientifically proven, provides a lens through which individuals examine their traits and life choices.

Mark Fennell, a self-proclaimed Sagittarius, finds some truth in the traits attributed to his star sign, despite his disbelief in astrology's scientific basis. This contradiction highlights why so many people find astrology compelling, even if they approach it with skepticism. Historically, astrology has deep roots, stretching back to ancient civilizations like Mesopotamia. Despite its cultural significance, research from Sweden indicates no correlation between compatible star signs and lower divorce rates. This data suggests astrology's influence is more introspective than factual.

The episode also examines the therapeutic potential of tarot cards. Unlike astrology, tarot readings provide a structured way to explore personal narratives and introspection, akin to traditional therapy methods. Ryan Finlay, a guest on the podcast, discusses how tarot can complement therapy by fostering a reflective space for clients. Susan Krauss Whitburn, a psychology professor, adds that while astrology can initiate introspection, it is not the most rewarding path compared to evidence-based therapeutic methods.

The episode encourages listeners to consider the balance between seeking guidance from the universe and relying on scientific understanding. In conclusion, while astrology and tarot might not hold scientific validity, they offer individuals a unique way to explore their inner dynamics and life choices. Whether viewed as cognitive traps or therapeutic tools, their role in introspection and cultural history remains significant.

Podcast buttons

Do you want to link to this podcast?
Get the buttons here!