Augusta Is Amazing But Its Only The Third Best Major

Augusta Is Amazing But Its Only The Third Best Major

Henry westons old mate the podcast

Stuart Butler ranks golf’s majors and explains why, despite his affection for Augusta, the Masters only comes third behind the Open Championship and the US Open. He contrasts raw links golf, brutal US Open setups and Augusta’s experience-driven familiarity in a short, opinionated Masters-week chat.

InformativeAuthenticHonestEngagingEntertaining

6:586 Apr 2026

RSS Feed

Why Augusta Only Comes Third on Stuart Butler’s Major List

Episode Overview

  • Ranks the Open Championship as the top major for its links turf, firm ground and unpredictable weather.
  • Places the US Open second due to its brutal setup, tight fairways, punishing rough and fast greens.
  • Explains why the Masters at Augusta is third, despite its iconic status and strong traditions.
  • Highlights how Augusta rewards course knowledge and experience, leading to repeat contenders.
  • Contrasts Augusta’s familiarity with the raw unpredictability of the Open and the severe test of the US Open.
At Augusta, you don’t just play the course, you remember it.

What drives someone to seek a life without alcohol? On Henry Weston’s old mate, that question usually sits alongside chats about mental health and life on the course, but this time the focus is firmly on golf’s biggest stages. Stuart Butler kicks off Masters week with a short, punchy breakdown of why Augusta, for all its drama and tradition, is only his third favourite major.

You’ll hear him rank the Open Championship at the top, calling it “everything I love about golf” – links turf, firm ground, balls running along the floor and weather that can give you “four seasons in a day”. He paints the Open as golf at its rawest: exposed, unpredictable and ruled by the elements rather than picture-perfect swings. Second place goes to the US Open, which Stuart describes as “a completely different beast”.

The colours, the familiarity and the history all get plenty of praise, but he explains how that same familiarity slightly dulls the edge: “At Augusta, you don’t just play the course, you remember it.” He highlights how experience is rewarded, with names like Phil Mickelson, Tiger Woods, Fred Couples and Bernhard Langer constantly reappearing on leaderboards because they “know every slope, every bailout, every mistake to avoid.” The episode is ideal if you enjoy strong opinions on golf’s majors, explained in everyday language with a bit of humour.

Tight fairways, punishing rough and fast, firm greens turn it into “the ultimate examination” where survival matters more than pretty golf. He’s honest that it can tip into unfairness, yet argues that once a year that level of brutality keeps things fascinating. Augusta and the Masters take bronze, even though he clearly loves the place. It’s a quick hit of Masters-week chat that might make you rethink which major really has your heart.

So where would you rank Augusta on your own list?

Podcast buttons

Do you want to link to this podcast?
Get the buttons here!