But I Prayed for This! What to Do When Living in God’s Yes Is Harder Than You Expected with Melissa Miller!But I Prayed for This! What to Do When Living in God’s Yes Is Harder Than You Expected with Melissa Miller!
Anchored by the Sword
Author Melissa Miller shares her journey from a non‑Christian upbringing to faith, adoption and trauma‑informed parenting, all framed through the tension of praying for something and then finding it harder than expected. She offers language, scripture and practical frameworks for those wrestling with shame and exhaustion after big answered prayers.
34:56•19 Aug 2026
When God Says Yes and Life Still Feels Hard with Melissa Miller
Episode Overview
- Answered prayers often bring big life changes, and the adjustment period can feel overwhelming without meaning that the blessing was a mistake.
- Naming “change fatigue” helps validate the exhaustion that comes from multiple transitions like adoption, relocation and new work all at once.
- Safe, compassionate community and therapy can break shame, since “shame will die in the presence of a compassionate witness.”
- Seeing life through the four seasons of blessing and the WHOLE framework encourages caring for body, mind, spirit and relationships together.
- Anchoring in scriptures about God’s unchanging nature offers stability when emotions, circumstances and even identity feel unsteady.
“Shame will die in the presence of a compassionate witness.”
What emotional and inspiring tales of recovery are out there? This conversation with author Melissa Miller speaks straight to anyone who’s ever prayed hard for something, got a “yes”… and then felt blindsided by how hard that yes turned out to be.
Melissa shares how she came to faith as a college student from a non‑Christian home, moved by a chalkboard question from an atheist professor: “If you knew there was a God, would you change your life today?” That moment sparked a journey that eventually led to marriage, five children (including two adopted from foster care), and a whole lot of unexpected stretching.
Talking about her book *But I Prayed for This: What to Do When Living in God’s Yes Is Harder Than You Expected*, Melissa unpacks “change fatigue” and the shame that creeps in when blessings feel heavier than hoped.
Adoption, relocation, a new job and trauma‑informed parenting all collided, leaving her feeling like she’d “woken up in somebody else’s life” and whispering, “But I prayed for this… I should feel different.” She offers a powerful reframe: “Shame will die in the presence of a compassionate witness,” stressing the need for safe community, honest church conversations and sometimes a good therapist.
Melissa also talks through her four “seasons of blessing” (Blooming, Building, Balancing and Bittersweet) and her WHOLE framework, which looks at wellness, home, occupation, life with God and engagement in relationships as one interconnected life rather than separate boxes.
Anchored in verses about God’s unchanging nature—“Jesus is the same yesterday, today, and forever” and “God is the upholder of my life”—this episode is especially helpful for those in recovery or major life transition who feel guilty for struggling after big answered prayers. If you’ve ever thought, “I wanted this… so why am I drowning?”, this might be the gentle permission to exhale you’ve been waiting for.
Do you want to link to this podcast?
Get the buttons here!
More From This Show
The latest episodes from the same podcast.