Changing Seats on the Titanic? Gambling, Nicotine & Replacement AddictionsChanging Seats on the Titanic? Gambling, Nicotine & Replacement Addictions
Recovery in the Middle Ages - Two Middle-Aged Suburban Dads Talk About Recovering From Addiction to Drugs & Alcohol.
Mike and Nat chat about what tends to replace alcohol once people quit, from gambling and nicotine pouches to meds and THC drinks. Their conversation mixes humour with concern as they question whether these substitutes are harm reduction or just new addictions in disguise.
1:11:42•19 Sept 2026
What Fills the Hole? Replacement Addictions and Middle-Aged Sobriety
Episode Overview
- Stopping alcohol often leaves a very real daily gap that many people instinctively try to fill with other behaviours or substances.
- Online sports betting and prediction markets are linked to rising gambling-related emergency room visits, especially among young men.
- Nicotine pouches and vapes are widely used as post-drink crutches, raising questions about harm reduction versus simply shifting addiction.
- Medication for alcohol use disorder (such as naltrexone and acamprosate) can be effective for some, and more new drugs are being developed.
- Non-alcoholic products are increasingly being infused with THC, blurring the line between sober alternatives and new forms of intoxication.
“Quitting like leaves a hole… Something has to fill your hole. The only question is what and whether you picked it or it picked you.”
Curious about how others navigate their sobriety journey? This episode of *Recovery in the Middle Ages* zeroes in on what happens after you put the drink down and that infamous “five-o’clock-on-a-Tuesday hole” shows up. Two suburban dads, Mike and Nat, swap stories and stats about replacement addictions, asking bluntly: are people getting sober, or just changing seats on the Titanic?
You’ll hear them joke their way into a serious question: “Quitting like leaves a hole… Something has to fill your hole. The only question is what and whether you picked it or it picked you.” From there, they walk through modern substitutes for alcohol: online sports betting that’s sending young men to emergency rooms in record numbers, prediction markets dressed up as “trading platforms”, and nicotine pouches like ZYN that have quietly become standard issue for many newly sober folks.
The chat also stretches into medication for alcohol use disorder, with Mike and Nat running through naltrexone, acamprosate and disulfiram, and noting how more than 25 companies are chasing new pills in a space where only three medications are currently approved. They wrestle with the disease model of addiction versus a spectrum idea, debating whether harmful coping and genetics make this a "disease" or something else.
Non-alcoholic drinks get their turn too: booming sober months, permanent mocktail menus, and then the twist—THC being added to “NA” beverages so they actually do something. Is that harm reduction, or just the same old lure in a different bottle? All of this comes wrapped in middle-aged banter, workplace stress, parenting worries, and plenty of sarcasm, keeping heavy topics feel down-to-earth and very human.
If you’ve ever wondered what might quietly be replacing your old habits, this chat might nudge you to ask: what’s filling your hole—and did you choose it?
Do you want to link to this podcast?
Get the buttons here!
More From This Show
The latest episodes from the same podcast.