Dopey Total Replay #45: Nick Reiner’s First Dopey Interview: 18 Rehabs, Harm Reduction, a GHB Overdose & Alina LodgeDopey Total Replay #45: Nick Reiner’s First Dopey Interview: 18 Rehabs, Harm Reduction, a GHB Overdose & Alina Lodge
Dopey: On the Dark Comedy of Drug Addiction
Timestamps 00:00:23 – Why today’s replay is so heavy 00:01:00 – Nick Reiner and the deaths of Rob and Michele Reiner 00:01:34 – Was replaying Nick’s interviews opportunistic? 00:02:47 – Why Dave refuses to remove an episode from Total Replay 00:03:05 – DopeyCon, costumes and tickets 00:04:06 – Leah’s letter about mental illness and identifying with Nick 00:07:32 – Compassion for Nick without minimizing what happened 00:09:12 – Dave’s response and contact from a potential defense attorney 00:09:58 – Patreon comments about Chris and Dopey’s future 00:14:44 – Spotify comments and favorite drug songs 00:16:53 – Original 2016 interview with Nick Reiner begins 00:18:55 – Dave lies his way onto Howard Stern while high 00:21:14 – Rob Reiner, Stand by Me and Being Charlie 00:23:32 – Nick’s problems with AA and the rehab industry 00:25:47 – God, twelve-step dogma and different definitions of sobriety 00:28:09 – Nick’s argument for harm reduction 00:30:30 – Bill Wilson, LSD and alternative pathways 00:32:51 – Nick uses a Soberlink during the interview 00:35:02 – Does long-term sobriety automatically create wisdom? 00:37:17 – Why Nick stopped counting sober days 00:38:00 – The psychiatrist who understood research chemicals 00:39:38 – Suboxone, Ashtanga yoga and treating the whole person 00:42:00 – Relapsing during a trip with his girlfriend 00:44:10 – Maslow, self-actualization and Rat Park 00:46:31 – The rats who continued using heroin 00:48:54 – Genetic addiction versus substance-use disorder 00:49:35 – Promoting Being Charlie while privately smoking weed 00:51:10 – Getting high after television appearances 00:53:15 – Who should be allowed to appear on Dopey? 00:55:31 – Recovery podcasts and the East Side Crackhead 00:57:45 – Dave and Chris clash over harm reduction 00:59:58 – Weed, chocolate and addiction to tomorrow 01:02:21 – The former IV drug user who returned to drinking 01:04:42 – Chris’s advice about Dave smoking weed 01:05:35 – Nick reveals that he has attended 17 or 18 rehabs 01:07:04 – Dave makes prison alcohol at Alina Lodge and escapes 01:09:12 – Crack in Harlem and the Blue Mountain Blast GHB 01:11:26 – Waking up in the hospital as “Charles McCullough” 01:13:43 – Nick’s experience at Alina Lodge 01:15:51 – Cocaine and the shower encounter 01:18:08 – Nick learns that the woman died by suicide 01:20:12 – Cry Help and the rehab prank call 01:22:16 – Part-one conclusion
1:23:47•14 Sept 2026
Heavy Replay: Nick Reiner, Harm Reduction and a Tragic Turn
Episode Overview
- Dave explains his commitment to replaying every Dopey episode, even when the timing around Nick Reiner’s case feels painful and controversial.
- Leah’s email highlights how severe mental illness can mirror addiction struggles and raises difficult questions about compassion for someone accused of a horrific crime.
- Nick openly challenges high-priced rehabs that sell 12-step based programmes and talks about feeling pushed into being a ‘sober’ spokesperson while still using.
- A detailed debate unfolds between Nick, Dave and Chris on harm reduction versus complete abstinence, grounded in their very different personal experiences.
- Nick shares darkly comic and disturbing stories from his using days, including a GHB overdose in Harlem and strict, isolating conditions at Alina Lodge.
“"He's the monster now and people want him dead. And I just can't stop thinking if it was a psychotic break or something and he didn't know what he was doing."”
How do people cope with the challenges of staying sober when tragedy keeps piling up? This replay of Nick Reiner’s first Dopey appearance lands at a brutal moment: Nick is now in L.A. County Jail, charged with the murder of his parents, beloved couple Rob and Michele Reiner. Host Dave explains why he’s sticking with his promise to replay every episode, even when the timing feels "extremely loaded" and criticism about being opportunistic is loud.
You’ll hear Dave read a powerful email from Leah, a self-described "normie" with severe mental illness who saw herself in Nick’s earlier struggles and now wrestles with compassion for him alongside horror at what happened. Her line, "He's the monster now and people want him dead," captures the moral knot many in the Dopey Nation feel, and Dave doesn’t pretend to have easy answers.
The episode then rolls into the original 2016 chat with Nick, a writer who’s been to 17–18 rehabs and talks bluntly about treatment, AA, and harm reduction. He questions rehab models that charge huge sums to deliver a free 12-step programme, argues that some people can use less-lethal substances without their lives collapsing, and contrasts that with Dave’s and Chris’s all-or-nothing experience.
The conversation mixes dark humour (including a chaotic GHB overdose in Harlem and the strictness of Alina Lodge) with real unease about what “sobriety” even means. Threaded through are Patreon and Spotify comments from long-time fans reflecting on Chris’s death, favourite drug songs, and how Dopey has helped them stay clean. It’s messy, sad, funny, and very human—exactly what someone wrestling with addiction, grief, or mixed feelings about harm reduction might relate to.
If you’re juggling compassion, anger, and confusion around addiction and tragedy, how do you hold all of that without looking away?
Do you want to link to this podcast?
Get the buttons here!
More From This Show
The latest episodes from the same podcast.