How to Choose a Psychotherapist: The Ultimate GuideHow to Choose a Psychotherapist: The Ultimate Guide
The Self-Love Recovery Podcast
Ross Rosenberg and Dr. Stephen Ross talk through how to choose a psychotherapist, from licences and specialties to personality fit and ethics. The conversation offers concrete questions and reassurance for anyone unsure about starting therapy or reconsidering their current therapist.
37:42•22 Jun 2026
How to Pick the Right Psychotherapist Without Selling Yourself Short
Episode Overview
- Ask direct questions about a therapist’s orientation, licence, years in practice, and experience with your specific issue before committing long term.
- Consider gender and age preferences, but also reflect on why they matter and stay open to therapists who might not match your initial picture.
- Look for licenced professionals and meaningful certifications, as these indicate accountability, ongoing education, and verified competence.
- If you’re not improving—especially after years—question the work, set boundaries, and don’t be afraid to change therapist or seek a specialist.
- Insurance panels can limit access; sometimes paying out of pocket less frequently or using out-of-network benefits is worth it for the right fit.
“This is your life. Don’t undercut yourself. Look for someone that fits, that you need, you want, and it works for you.”
What can we learn from those who have battled addiction? For anyone trying to heal from codependency, trauma, addiction, or narcissistic abuse, finding the right therapist can feel like a minefield. In this conversation, master psychotherapist Ross Rosenberg sits down with clinical psychologist and marriage and family therapist Dr. Stephen Ross to break down how to choose a psychotherapist who actually fits your needs.
Right from the start, they tackle the questions many people are too shy to ask: What should you ask in that first phone call? How much do orientation, licensure, and years in practice really matter? You’ll hear them suggest simple but powerful questions like, “What is your theory?” and, “How do you know when a client gets to a better place?”—practical prompts that help you quickly sense whether someone’s style makes sense for you.
They talk frankly about preferences around gender and age, with Ross stressing that, “you get to choose if they’re female or male, you get to choose their age,” while also encouraging you to think about *why* you’re making that choice and whether someone outside that preference might still be a great fit.
The pair also unpack the often-confusing alphabet soup of degrees, licences, and certifications, explaining why licensure is a strong indicator of accountability and why, after five to ten years in the field, good therapists tend to look more similar than different. Ethics and boundaries are a big theme. They call out therapists who keep clients for years without real progress, and Ross urges people not to be afraid of changing therapist if things are stuck: “This is your life.
Don’t undercut yourself.” Insurance frustrations, out-of-network options, and seeing a specialist for issues like addiction, eating disorders, or trauma are handled in clear, down-to-earth language. If you’ve ever wondered whether your therapist is the right one—or how to pick your first—this conversation offers concrete questions and gentle permission to put your needs first. What kind of therapist do *you* actually deserve?
Do you want to link to this podcast?
Get the buttons here!
More From This Show
The latest episodes from the same podcast.
Related Episodes
Similar episodes from other shows in the catalogue.