Moving Beyond 12-Step Recovery! Are You Ready?

Moving Beyond 12-Step Recovery! Are You Ready?

Audio/Video – The Freedom Model For Addictions

Mark Sheeran and Michelle Dunbar question 12‑step recovery, sharing their experiences in AA and why they now reject the idea of powerlessness. They outline how The Freedom Model aims to help people leave a recovery identity behind and move beyond 12‑step programmes.

HonestEye-openingInspiringInformativeNon-judgmental

33:1813 May 2026

RSS Feed

Moving On From 12-Step: Mark & Michelle Challenge the Recovery Trap

Episode Overview

  • Mark and Michelle argue that addiction is a temporary problem and not a disease, and that people are never truly powerless over substances.
  • They state their criticism is aimed at AA’s dogma and ideology, not individuals, and claim most people do not benefit long-term from 12-step programmes.
  • Both hosts share family and personal stories showing how AA involvement can overshadow children, partners, work and normal life.
  • They describe how AA teaches people to credit meetings and recovery culture for change, rather than their own decision to stop or moderate.
  • Their upcoming live event aims to help those who feel stuck or uneasy in 12-step recovery to deconstruct 12-step myths and move on from a recovery identity.
"You don't have a disease. You know you don't have a disease. You know."

How do people cope with the challenges of staying sober? This episode of The Freedom Model for Addictions takes that question and turns it on its head, arguing that most people never needed a life-long recovery identity in the first place. Alcohol and drug use are framed very differently here.

Mark Sheeran and Michelle Dunbar call out what they describe as the "recovery cult" around 12-step programmes, saying their issue isn’t with people in Alcoholics Anonymous, but with the ideas being taught. They talk through their decades in AA, how they became sceptical, and why they now see addiction as a temporary problem rather than a life-long disease.

You’ll hear Mark share painful memories of his mother becoming “completely, totally devoted to AA” and putting the fellowship above her twelve children, while Michelle recalls being taken to meetings from the age of nine and later being told she’d “die” for falling in love in early sobriety. Their stories highlight how an AA-centred life can end up replacing family, friends and ordinary responsibilities. A big chunk of the conversation focuses on powerlessness.

They promise to "show you that you've never been powerless" and argue that people decide to change before they ever step into a meeting, but then get taught to give all the credit to the programme rather than their own choices. They describe AA as "Bill Wilson's book of fiction" and say much of the ideology creates confusion, fear and lifelong self-doubt.

The episode builds towards their live event, "Move Beyond 12-Step Recovery", aimed at those who feel they’ve outgrown meetings or are stuck in a cycle of so‑called "chronic relapse". The message is blunt but hopeful: there’s nothing wrong with you, and you can move on from a recovery identity. If you’ve ever sat in a meeting thinking, "This feels off, but I don’t know why," this conversation might be the nudge you’ve been waiting for.

Podcast buttons

Do you want to link to this podcast?
Get the buttons here!

More From This Show

The latest episodes from the same podcast.