Natalie Eva Marie on Soccer, DUIs, Jail, WWE Divas, "Graduating" AA, NEM Fitness, Her Recent Divorce and Starting Over AgainNatalie Eva Marie on Soccer, DUIs, Jail, WWE Divas, "Graduating" AA, NEM Fitness, Her Recent Divorce and Starting Over Again
Chasing Heroine: Addiction Recovery Podcast
Natalie Eva Marie shares her journey from college soccer and DUIs to WWE fame, relapse, long‑term sobriety and a recent divorce. The conversation focuses on addiction, recovery tools, faith and what starting over in her forties currently looks like.
2:01:54•30 Jul 2026
From WWE Red Hair to Starting Over: Natalie Eva Marie’s Raw Recovery Story
Episode Overview
- Early depression and self‑worth issues can exist even in supportive families, and may fuel later addiction.
- Fear of failure and self‑doubt led Natalie to walk away from promising soccer opportunities she now sees as a key lesson.
- Multiple DUIs, jail time and failed rehab attempts highlight how powerful denial and addiction can be, even after serious consequences.
- Long‑term sobriety for Natalie depends on consistent meetings, sponsorship, service work and a strong spiritual connection rather than just willpower.
- Starting over after divorce means accepting loss, rebuilding businesses and routines, and remembering that social media doesn’t show the full struggle.
“"You don’t get to rehab on a winning streak. You walk in there because you’re losing and you’re on life support at that point."”
What remarkable journeys have people faced head‑on against addiction? This one starts with college soccer dreams, runs through jail cells and wrestling rings, and lands in a brand‑new chapter of life at 42. Here, Natalie Eva Marie shares a version of her story that’s far beyond the red hair and WWE fame.
You’ll hear about growing up as the youngest of all boys in a strict Mexican‑Italian household, feeling "born straight out the womb as an addict", and the early depression and self‑doubt she carried long before her first drink. From keg parties and blackouts to multiple DUIs and three months in county jail, nothing is glossed over.
She talks openly about falling in love with cocaine in a bathroom stall, disappearing into a blacked‑out trap apartment for months, and trying outpatient rehab while still failing every drug test. A key turning point comes when a sober brother nudges her back into AA, where a church coincidence leads her to Mo, the sponsor who’s still in her life today.
Then it shifts: a four‑week WWE tryout, the unexpected call that changes everything, and the surreal leap from sharing a bed with a friend to filming Total Divas and wrestling around the world. Natalie explains how she built three years of sobriety, "graduated" AA, relapsed, and then found long‑term recovery again—with 13 years now under her belt.
Most raw is her first public talk about her recent divorce: choosing safety over true desire, splitting after 13 sober years together, selling her house, and feeling like she’s "starting all over" while rebuilding NEM Fitness and her recovery work. Throughout, she comes back to meetings, sponsorship, faith, and the reminder that social media is a highlight reel, not real life.
If you’ve ever wondered how someone can lose everything, rebuild it, and still question their worth, this conversation might make you rethink what starting over can actually mean.
Do you want to link to this podcast?
Get the buttons here!
More From This Show
The latest episodes from the same podcast.