People First Radio – March 20, 2025People First Radio – March 20, 2025
People First Radio
Researcher Yasmin Simone Gray shares why she resists the label of mental illness, speaking about trauma, discrimination and the limits of traditional psychiatric care. The conversation highlights holistic mental health, the importance of community support, and a gentler way of understanding distress by asking, "What happened?" instead of "What’s wrong with me?"
0:00•21 Mar 2025
Language, Labels and Community: Rethinking Mental Health with Yasmin Simone Gray
Episode Overview
- Questioning the label of “mental illness” can help shift blame from the individual to unjust social, economic and racist systems.
- Suicidal thoughts may signal that something in a person’s life or environment needs attention, and responses that remove autonomy can be deeply harmful.
- Mental health is described as holistic, involving housing, food, income, safety, community and anti-oppressive conditions, not just individual diagnosis.
- Community care—active listening, small acts of support and mutual accommodation—can be a vital complement where formal services are limited or unsafe.
- Instead of asking “What’s wrong with me?”, reframing the question to “What happened?” can foster greater self-compassion and reduce internalised blame.
“Instead of asking myself constantly, what's wrong with me? I ask myself, well, what happened?”
How much of our distress belongs to us, and how much belongs to a society that keeps piling on pressure? This question sits at the heart of this People First Radio conversation with researcher and complex trauma survivor Yasmin Simone Gray. Aimed at anyone wrestling with mental health labels—especially those juggling trauma, racism, poverty, disability or queerness—this episode gently challenges the idea that feeling overwhelmed automatically means you’re “mentally ill”.
Gray explains why she resists that label, saying she prefers to locate the problem in “a society that has sickness and illness and individualism as some of the core issues,” rather than in her own brain chemistry. The chat with host Joe Pugh moves between personal experience and policy-level critique. You’ll hear how mainstream approaches to suicide often strip people of autonomy, and why Gray calls involuntary psychiatric care “extremely violent” for many.
She contrasts a psychiatrist who told her she’d “never be able to complete a university degree” with a counsellor who simply listened and helped her see that some of her reactions were reasonable responses to abuse and structural injustice. Gray also digs into language: how “mental health” gets used as a euphemism for “mental illness”, how “stigma” can hide what is really discrimination, and why labels attached in healthcare can follow people into every doctor’s appointment afterwards.
She repeatedly comes back to community—friends who listen, share notes, walk together, bring fruit, offer a cup of tea—as crucial, everyday care that doesn’t require a professional title. For anyone in recovery, supporting someone in crisis, or wondering how to be a better friend, this conversation asks a simple but powerful shift: instead of “What’s wrong with me?”, try “What happened?” How might your own story change if you started there?
Do you want to link to this podcast?
Get the buttons here!
More From This Show
The latest episodes from the same podcast.
Related Episodes
Similar episodes from other shows in the catalogue.