The Two Voices in Your Head: First Thought WrongThe Two Voices in Your Head: First Thought Wrong
RAW Recovery Podcast
Dion talks about the two voices in his head, using the idea of a good duck and a bad duck to explain “first thought wrong” and the power of pausing before acting. He shares humour, frustrations and practical tools for handling intrusive thoughts, integrity issues and everyday challenges in recovery.
35:32•15 Sept 2026
Good Duck, Bad Duck: Rethinking Your First Thought in Recovery
Episode Overview
- Having a reactive first thought doesn’t make someone a bad person; growth comes from questioning that thought instead of blindly following it.
- Pausing to check motives, facts, and feelings before acting can prevent unnecessary conflict and damage in recovery.
- Speaking fears, cravings and resentments out loud helps move them from fantasy into reality, where they lose power and can be addressed.
- Both the “good duck” and “bad duck” need balance; constant people‑pleasing can be just as harmful as constant defensiveness.
- Apparent problems, like sleepless nights or anxiety, can sometimes be unexpected forms of help and opportunities for character building.
“The first thought may be wrong, but the real growth is realizing I do not have to follow it just because it came from my own head.”
Curious about how others navigate their sobriety journey? This RAW Recovery Podcast instalment centres on the noisy debate going on inside every recovering brain: the fast, reactive voice versus the calmer, honest one. Dion, speaking from lived experience, turns this inner battle into a down‑to‑earth chat, complete with “good duck” and “bad duck” sitting on each shoulder.
Early on, he shifts from ranting about unethical behaviour in the recovery community to a more constructive focus on integrity: doing the right thing even when nobody’s watching, and not bragging about it afterwards. From there, the conversation moves into “first thought wrong” – those intrusive thoughts that show up before there’s time to examine them. As Dion puts it, the problem isn’t having the thought; it’s what happens if you blindly trust it.
He uses humour, family stories, and everyday irritations (including loud blue jays and Facebook warnings) to show how quickly suspicion, jealousy, and fear can build a false reality. Dion explains how pausing, checking motives and facts, and talking things out can stop a bad duck moment turning into a full‑blown drama. “It’s not real until it comes out of your mouth,” he says, urging people to speak fears and resentments out loud so they lose their power.
There’s also a nod to Al‑Anon readings and the idea that what looks like a problem might actually be a strange form of help from a higher power. Sleep issues, anxiety and obsessive worry are framed as opportunities for character building rather than proof that someone is failing at recovery.
If you’ve ever wondered whether you can trust your own head, or felt torn between people‑pleasing and self‑respect, this chat offers relatable stories and practical ways to give the right “duck” the microphone. Which voice in your head are you going to listen to today?
Do you want to link to this podcast?
Get the buttons here!
More From This Show
The latest episodes from the same podcast.