186. Does Hurt Shape Our Identity?186. Does Hurt Shape Our Identity?
Hope in Recovery
Andy Petry and Rodney Holmstrom talk about how past hurts can shape a wounded identity and feed addictive patterns. They share how Christ, safe community, and the Celebrate Recovery process can help address those wounds and reshape how people see themselves.
33:52•26 May 2026
Does Hurt Define Who We Are? Andy and Rodney Talk Wounded Identity
Episode Overview
- Hurt can’t change a person’s identity in Christ, but unaddressed wounds can distort how they see themselves and behave.
- Emotions are described as honest indicators of what someone believes, helping surface lies such as “I’m a failure” or “I’m unlovable.”
- Simply trying to think differently is likened to fixing the wrong problem; real change comes from addressing the original hurt.
- Avoidance and indulgence are presented as common but unhelpful coping strategies, with safe relationships and Jesus offered as better options.
- Celebrate Recovery is framed as a journey from stability, to dealing with past wounds, to repairing relationships and building healthier connections.
“The danger is not a wounded identity. The danger is unaddressed wounded identity.”
Curious about how others navigate their sobriety journey? This conversation from Hope in Recovery zooms in on a question many in recovery quietly ask: does hurt shape who we think we are? Andy Petry and Rodney Holmstrom talk honestly about what they call a "wounded identity"—those deep beliefs like "I'm a failure" or "I'm unlovable" that can grow out of past hurts.
Rodney explains that, as a Christian, "in Christ we are sons and daughters of the almighty God," but in a broken world our identity can be "hijacked" by pain and distorted into something very different. You’ll hear them unpack how unaddressed wounds can fuel hang-ups and habits, from addictions to avoidance and overreaction.
Rodney points out that emotions "are very honest because they're revealing what I'm believing," and that simply telling yourself to "just stop it" is like "repairing my refrigerator when my water heater's broke." Instead, they suggest asking, "When did I first believe that?" and tracing today’s reactions back to specific moments of hurt.
The episode also walks through how Celebrate Recovery is structured: first building stability and a relationship with Jesus, then doing the deeper “surgery” of inventory and amends, and finally stepping into healthier relationships and service. Along the way, shame, defensiveness, and shutting down are reframed as protection strategies hiding a deeper longing to be loved and received.
Grounded in Christ-centred recovery and plenty of personal honesty, this chat is especially helpful if you're wrestling with old stories about yourself that just won’t let go. As Rodney says, "It makes sense" to feel this way—but you don’t have to face it on your own. Could it be time to let someone into those wounds so they stop running the show?

Do you want to link to this podcast?
Get the buttons here!
More From This Show
The latest episodes from the same podcast.
Related Episodes
Similar episodes from other shows in the catalogue.
