358: Can I Drink In Moderation?358: Can I Drink In Moderation?
Soberful
Veronica Valli and Chip Somers talk frankly about why moderation is so rarely achievable for anyone with an alcohol problem. They challenge common beliefs about "social drinking" and offer a more hopeful view of life lived fully sober.
46:19•15 Jul 2026
Can I Drink in Moderation, or Is That Just a Delusion?
Episode Overview
- Once you’re worrying about your drinking, it’s already a sign of an alcohol problem, not a pre-problem phase.
- Most people with alcohol issues have tried moderation many times before and found it consistently fails.
- Underlying trauma, anxiety and low self-worth are key drivers of problem drinking, not just the alcohol itself.
- Early sobriety often feels socially uncomfortable, but that feeling passes with time and practice.
- Letting go of the moderation fantasy can free up energy and mental bandwidth to build a fuller, more satisfying life.
“The reason that you think you want to drink moderately is a delusion. That's a delusion.”
What drives someone to seek a life without alcohol? Episode 358 of Soberful tackles one of the biggest questions people have about drinking: "Can I drink in moderation?" Veronica Valli and Chip Somers, both long-time sobriety experts, unpack why moderation feels like the holy grail for anyone with an alcohol use disorder and why it almost always backfires. You’ll hear them explain that people who don’t have a problem with alcohol simply don’t spend time worrying about it.
As Veronica puts it, once drinking is renting space in your head, it’s already a sign something’s wrong. Chip compares the idea of "social drinking" after problem drinking to trying to "smoke socially" after quitting cigarettes – everyone knows exactly how that ends. The conversation is packed with relatable examples: promises to "only drink at weekends", switching from spirits to wine, or setting rules like "only after six".
They note that most people asking about moderation have tried all of these already, sometimes dozens of times, and still ended up back where they started. One standout moment comes when Veronica says, "The reason that you think you want to drink moderately is a delusion. That's a delusion." For many, that line might sting, but it’s backed up by years of seeing the same pattern repeat.
They also talk about the fear underneath the moderation question – the worry that without alcohol there’ll be no fun, no connection, no excitement. Chip gently challenges this by stressing that early sobriety can feel uncomfortable, but with patience, confidence grows and genuine enjoyment returns without the chaos alcohol brings.
There’s even a humorous "shark-infested water" analogy about the odds of successful moderation, followed by a more hopeful image of a boat to a different island where people enjoy life sober. If you’ve ever wondered whether you’re the exception who can make moderation work, this episode may prompt you to ask a tougher, more honest question: what is alcohol really costing you?
Do you want to link to this podcast?
Get the buttons here!
More From This Show
The latest episodes from the same podcast.