Addiction, identity & 'denial' with Professor Hanna PickardAddiction, identity & 'denial' with Professor Hanna Pickard
The Alcohol 'Problem' Podcast
Dr James Morris and Professor Hannah Pickard talk about addiction as more than a brain disease or moral failing, focusing on stigma, denial and identity. They discuss “responsibility without blame” and the complex mix of psychology, culture and social context that shapes alcohol problems and recovery.
50:37•9 Apr 2026
Addiction, Denial and Who We Are Without Alcohol
Episode Overview
- Addiction is poorly captured by a simple split between disease and moral weakness, and both models carry different kinds of stigma.
- “Responsibility without blame” offers a way to support change by recognising agency while avoiding punitive, shaming responses.
- Denial around alcohol problems is linked to common human cognitive biases and the real emotional and social value substances can have.
- Cultural norms around drinking make it easier to minimise alcohol harms but also provide a lever for population-level change.
- Effective understanding and support for addiction require attention to heterogeneity, personal identity and social context, not just brain-based explanations.
“We have to get better at recognising that grey zone as opposed to always oscillating between these black and white extreme options.”
How do people cope with the challenges of staying sober when the very language around addiction can feel stigmatising or limiting? This conversation between Dr James Morris and Professor Hannah Pickard digs into that messy middle ground where real lives are lived. Aimed at people interested in alcohol problems, treatment, and policy, the episode looks at why the old choice between “disease” and “moral weakness” just doesn’t cut it.
Pickard argues that the dominant brain disease model may reduce blame, but still brings stigma and a sense that the person is broken beyond their own influence. As she puts it, calling addiction a brain disease “has been a mixed blessing” – it supports medical care, yet can make people feel othered and hopeless. You’ll hear a clear, down-to-earth explanation of her idea of “responsibility without blame” – holding people accountable for change while dropping the judgment and hostility.
She contrasts this with the familiar swing between moral condemnation on one side and a “rescue stance” on the other, where people are treated as if they have no choice at all. Denial gets a fresh treatment too. Rather than a caricature of someone stubbornly refusing the obvious, Pickard connects it with everyday cognitive biases, wishful thinking, and the very real value alcohol or other drugs can hold – relief from distress, social identity, even a sense of belonging.
That makes it painfully hard to admit there’s a problem, especially in cultures where drinking is woven into normal life. Identity, recovery, and heterogeneity run through the whole chat. There’s no one story of addiction here: for some, honesty with themselves might be the turning point; for others, the bigger issue is having no meaningful life outside a drug-using community.
If you’re curious about more humane ways to think about addiction, stigma, and change, this episode might leave you asking how your own views could shift too.
Do you want to link to this podcast?
Get the buttons here!
More From This Show
The latest episodes from the same podcast.
Related Episodes
Similar episodes from other shows in the catalogue.