Does mental 'illness' exist?Does mental 'illness' exist?
All In The Mind
A leading professor of psychology says that seeing mental distress as an illness is the wrong approach. We need a model of care which supports people who are distressed due to their social and life circumstances.
28:52•12 Nov 2017
Rethinking Mental ‘Illness’: Why Distress Might Not Be a Disease
Episode Overview
- Mental and emotional distress is framed as part of normal human psychology, not as a separate disease entity.
- Social factors such as unemployment, bullying, abuse and war are described as clear drivers of mental health problems.
- The episode challenges over-reliance on diagnostic labels and encourages using everyday and scientific psychological language instead.
- Heavy use of psychiatric medication and a purely biological focus are questioned as weakly evidenced and often unhelpful.
- Kinderman argues for services that provide humane, safe support rooted in social justice rather than simply treating a supposed illness.
“"I think it's better to regard these terrible issues as terrible aspects of normal psychology... rather than to suggest that they're sort of alien pathologies."”
In this eye-opening episode, you'll learn about a radical rethink of what we call "mental illness" and why that label might be doing more harm than good. Psychologist and former British Psychological Society president Peter Kinderman joins host Lynne Malcolm to argue that emotional distress should be seen as a human response to life circumstances, not a disease in the brain.
He's clear that the suffering is real, but he’s equally clear that the illness metaphor is misleading: "I think it's better to regard these terrible issues as terrible aspects of normal psychology... rather than to suggest that they're sort of alien pathologies." The conversation has a candid, sometimes angry tone as Kinderman rails against forced detention, power imbalances in services, and the lack of "safe, pleasant, calming, restorative places" for people in crisis.
Instead of asking "What is the aetiology of depression?", he suggests we ask why societies leave people feeling so hopeless. You’ll hear concrete examples, from ADHD being used as a label for children who don’t fit rigid schooling, to public health data showing suicide spikes after economic downturns. Kinderman repeatedly points to social factors—unemployment, bullying, abuse, gendered violence, war—as clear drivers of distress, and questions heavy reliance on medication and brain-based explanations.
Stylistically, the episode mixes clear scientific discussion with everyday language, swapping labels like "borderline personality disorder" and "major depressive disorder" for phrases such as self-harm, hopelessness, and relationship difficulties. The target audience includes anyone affected by mental health issues, those sceptical of purely medical models, and people wanting services grounded in social justice and humane care.
If you’ve ever wondered whether diagnosis and drugs are the full story, this conversation might leave you asking: what would mental health support look like if we started from people’s lives, rather than their labels?
Do you want to link to this podcast?
Get the buttons here!
More From This Show
The latest episodes from the same podcast.