Ep. 049: Insurance Fraud at a Detox: Pled Guilty but Tells a Different Story. You Decide.Ep. 049: Insurance Fraud at a Detox: Pled Guilty but Tells a Different Story. You Decide.
High While Clean presented by Recovery Ecosystem
Host Eric McCoy talks with former detox owner Dave Johnson about his insurance fraud case, sharing Dave’s version of events alongside the official allegations. The conversation looks at how insurance, ethics, and access to treatment collide, leaving the audience to decide what they think.
50:57•16 Jan 2021
Insurance Fraud or Broken System? Dave Johnson’s Controversial Detox Story
Episode Overview
- Eric describes how expanded insurance cover after the Affordable Care Act led to both wider access to treatment and widespread fraud in some programmes.
- Dave Johnson denies intentionally double-billing insurers, claiming the issue stemmed from an NPI change and that he repaid duplicate payments.
- He says hardship contracts, partial deductibles, and housing or job support were meant to keep clients safe and stable rather than to cheat insurance companies.
- Dave recounts raids, multiple arrests, lost evidence, and 16 months in custody before accepting a plea during Covid, saying he felt forced into it.
- Both men point to the long-term effect of fraud: insurers tightening payments, facilities closing, and people with addiction struggling to find detox and treatment.
“People out there are dying. You've got fentanyl out there now. Kids are dying all over. Unless you're an addict or a mother of a child out there that's suffering, maybe you don't understand what's going on.”
Curious about how others navigate their sobriety journey? High While Clean takes a sharp turn into the messy crossover of addiction treatment, insurance money, and the justice system. Host Eric McCoy talks with long-time acquaintance Dave Johnson, former owner of Southern California Detox, who was charged with 30 counts of insurance fraud and later pled guilty – but insists the story isn’t as simple as the headlines.
Eric opens by sketching how the Affordable Care Act reshaped treatment: more people could access rehab, but greed crept in. He describes programs buying insurance for clients, paying bounties for admissions, and even billing for people who weren’t in treatment. It’s a raw look at how a life-saving system became “absolutely insane” in places. Against that backdrop, Dave shares his version of events.
He denies setting up policies or deliberately double-billing, instead blaming an NPI number change and billing errors: “Health Net…continued to pay on it…which my billers noticed.” He says he repaid duplicate payments and claims his hardship contracts and partial deductible waivers were meant to keep clients in care, not to cheat insurers.
The conversation then moves into raids, search warrants, a client complaint, and Dave’s account of sitting in jail for 16 months while pushing for a jury trial, only to finally accept a plea during Covid restrictions. He calls many of the charges “trumped up” and insists evidence went missing. Both Eric and Dave agree that years of widespread fraud have triggered a harsh backlash from insurers, which now leaves many people unable to access treatment.
As Dave puts it, “People out there are dying… you’ve got fentanyl out there now.” This one’s aimed at anyone in recovery, loved ones, and treatment professionals who want a candid, sometimes uncomfortable look at how ethics, money, and human lives collide. Where do you land on Dave’s story after hearing both sides laid out?
Do you want to link to this podcast?
Get the buttons here!
More From This Show
The latest episodes from the same podcast.
Related Episodes
Similar episodes from other shows in the catalogue.