Should Mike Smoke Pot? Moral Relativism in Recovery & the Grateful Dead

Should Mike Smoke Pot? Moral Relativism in Recovery & the Grateful Dead

Recovery in the Middle Ages - Two Middle-Aged Suburban Dads Talk About Recovering From Addiction to Drugs & Alcohol.

Two suburban dads debate whether weed has any place in sobriety, weighing harm reduction against full abstinence while sharing personal stories and reflections. They also discuss Annie Grace’s *This Naked Mind*, alcohol marketing, and the pressure to define success in recovery by strict rules or day counts.

AuthenticHonestInformativeEncouragingSupportive

1:02:47•4 Sept 2020

RSS Feed

Should Mike Smoke Pot? Sobriety Lines, Moral Arguments and Grateful Dead Tales

Episode Overview

  • Swapping alcohol for cannabis may reduce drinking short term, but can still leave someone relying on an outside substance to cope.
  • Abstinence and harm reduction sit on a spectrum; what helps in a crisis may differ from what supports long-term recovery.
  • Using one slip to declare total failure can be harmful; progress can still be meaningful even with occasional setbacks.
  • Alcohol is framed as glamorous and normal through constant marketing, despite being a poisonous, addictive carcinogen.
  • There are many routes into recovery—AA, other groups, books like *This Naked Mind*—and people can experiment to see what fits their stage and needs.
“It's very strange that we live in a society structured so that people who are not ingesting what's essentially a poison are considered the ones with the problem.”

Curious about how others navigate their sobriety journey? Here, two middle‑aged suburban dads, Mike and Nat, kick around a question many people in recovery quietly wonder: is it ever okay to smoke weed if you’ve quit drinking? The chat starts loose and funny in the back room of a shop, but it quickly gets serious.

Mike admits that when he first quit alcohol, he gave himself permission to use cannabis as a kind of pressure valve: if cravings got bad, he’d smoke instead of drink. He explains, though, that, “at the end of the day, I don’t need anything… my life is so much better,” and he’s since taken that option off the table.

Nat pushes back from a more traditional 12‑step point of view, questioning whether swapping one substance for another can ever really be called recovery. He challenges the idea of “moral relativism” in sobriety: if some things are clearly harmful, is it honest to pretend they’re fine just because they’re legal or socially accepted? From there, the two dads riff on harm reduction versus full abstinence, the pressure of counting days, and whether a slip wipes out all progress.

They compare addiction to diets and allergies, arguing that someone who drinks once in a month after being daily drunk for years may still have had a “successful March.” You’ll also hear them talk about Annie Grace’s book *This Naked Mind*, especially her take on alcohol as a poisonous, addictive carcinogen wrapped in clever marketing. They use her “pitcher plant” analogy to show how anyone, not just so‑called “addictive personalities”, can get pulled deeper into drinking.

To keep things light, Mike shares some disastrous weed stories involving Grateful Dead–related gigs, jet‑strength cannabis, and hiding in a porta potty, plus a wild recovery‑in‑the‑news story about workplace drinking pressure in China. If you’ve ever wondered where you personally draw the line in recovery, this episode gives plenty to chew on. So where do you stand: harm reduction, abstinence, or still figuring it out?

Podcast buttons

Do you want to link to this podcast?
Get the buttons here!

More From This Show

The latest episodes from the same podcast.