The Feel Good AgendaThe Feel Good Agenda
Is This All There Is?
Todd Brossart reflects on Russ Harris’s idea of the "feel-good agenda" and four myths about happiness, questioning the belief that life should always feel good. The episode looks at how chasing relief from discomfort can limit meaningful action and highlights the value of accepting mixed emotions while acting on what matters.
7:10•21 Sept 2026
The Feel-Good Trap: Why Chasing Happiness Can Shrink Your Life
Episode Overview
- Happiness is not a constant natural state; believing it should be can increase suffering.
- Feeling distressed does not mean you are defective; the mind is doing what it evolved to do.
- Trying to eliminate negative feelings often blocks you from building a richer, more meaningful life.
- You have limited control over thoughts and feelings but significant control over your actions.
- Contentment and joy tend to arise from facing problems, sharing openly, learning skills, and staying present, not from avoiding discomfort.
“We experience contentment, joy, and happiness by overcoming problems, sharing with others what we feel and need, mastering a skill, and being available to the present moment, not avoiding it.”
What drives someone to seek a life that isn’t ruled by feeling good all the time? This episode of *Is This All There Is?* steps right into that tension, using Russ Harris’s "feel-good agenda" as a lens for looking at how many of us run our lives. Todd Brossart talks through the four big myths from *The Happiness Trap* and shows how they colour everyday choices, especially for people in high-stress caring roles like nursing, counselling, and addiction work.
You’ll hear how ideas such as "happiness is the natural state" and "if you’re not happy, you’re defective" quietly ramp up shame and self-criticism when life actually feels messy, exhausting, or painful. The episode highlights how a feel-good culture pushes you to chase positive emotions while trying to wipe out the uncomfortable ones.
As the transcript puts it, "it's pretty impossible to create a better life if you're not prepared to have some uncomfortable feelings." Instead of treating distress as proof that something is wrong with you, Todd leans into Harris’s perspective: "You're not defective. Your mind's just doing what it evolved to do." Rather than promising yet another quick fix, the conversation focuses on action and values.
You’ll hear how meaningful work, close relationships, and real growth come with mixed emotions—stress and anxiety right alongside joy and connection. The episode questions the idea that you must control every thought and feeling before you can act, stressing that "we do have a huge amount of control over our actions" even when our inner world isn’t tidy.
For anyone in recovery, burnt out in healthcare, or just tired of chasing permanent happiness, this is a grounded, honest look at why trying to "feel better" at all costs can actually shrink your life. It gently asks: what might change if you stopped living mainly to avoid feeling bad, and started acting for what matters, even when it doesn’t feel good yet?
Do you want to link to this podcast?
Get the buttons here!
More From This Show
The latest episodes from the same podcast.