Why People Leave Christianity After Church HurtWhy People Leave Christianity After Church Hurt
The Call with Nancy Sabato
Nancy Sabato talks with Pedro Garcia about how church hurt and emotional pain led him away from Christianity and into atheism. Their conversation focuses on doubt, surrender, and finding identity in Jesus apart from those who misrepresent him.
8:34•9 Jul 2026
Why Church Hurt Pushes People From Faith – And How Surrender Brings Them Back
Episode Overview
- Pedro Garcia explains that emotional pain, more than pure intellect, often sits behind decisions to leave Christianity.
- He describes "intellectual shielding" as using clever arguments to hide unprocessed hurt.
- A childhood incident with a priest, and being asked to lie about it, pushed him towards atheism and away from Jesus.
- Pedro stresses that salvation and identity in Jesus come first, even during seasons of doubt and uncertainty.
- He highlights surrender—letting go of what controls you—as key to receiving grace and finding a healthier, restored faith.
“My atheism came from an emotional breakage.”
What can we learn from those who have battled addiction, doubt, and disappointment in faith? This conversation between host Nancy Sabato and guest Pedro Garcia looks straight at the painful subject of church hurt and why so many people walk away from Christianity because of it. Pedro shares a childhood story that shook his faith: a bipolar priest throwing a chair at him in class, then another priest asking him and his father to lie about it.
As a boy, he couldn’t separate the behaviour of those claiming to follow Jesus from Jesus himself, so he put them "in one box" and eventually embraced atheism. He admits that his rejection of faith was deeply emotional: "My atheism came from an emotional breakage," he says, and describes how he later used intellectual arguments against Christianity as a kind of armour.
You’ll hear him talk about "intellectual shielding"—building clever arguments to cover raw pain—and why he thinks emotional wounds are the main reason people leave Christianity. The chat doesn’t stay in the hurt though. Nancy and Pedro move into how doubt can actually lead to a stronger faith, rooted in the idea that salvation and identity in Jesus come first, even when feelings and circumstances are all over the place.
Pedro uses a memorable picture: in "The University of Jesus", you’re handed the degree at the door, then learn to live from it. That leads into his central theme of surrender—opening your clenched fist so "your hand is open to receive more grace from Jesus".
For anyone who’s been injured by church leaders, feels spiritually lost, or struggles to separate Jesus from those who misrepresented him, this heartfelt chat offers honesty, a bit of gentle humour, and a steady reminder: the pain is real, but it doesn’t have to have the last word.
Do you want to link to this podcast?
Get the buttons here!
More From This Show
The latest episodes from the same podcast.