041: Living on Autopilot and Calling It Functioning041: Living on Autopilot and Calling It Functioning
The Shift Show
Andrea McTague and Kai Ongaro talk about living on autopilot, where life looks functional but feels flat and joyless. They connect this pattern to chronic stress and limiting beliefs, and explain how shifting those beliefs can create more space for boundaries, choice and genuine enjoyment.
24:18•8 Jul 2026
Living on Autopilot: Why ‘Functioning’ Feels Like a Five Out of Ten
Episode Overview
- Autopilot often looks like a ‘solid five out of ten’ life where everything works on the surface but feels emotionally flat and joyless.
- Chronic, layered stress and global limiting beliefs such as “I’m irresponsible”, “I’m worthless” or “I’m not in control” push people into over-functioning and burnout.
- The “walnut brain” (threat system) keeps people focused on avoiding pain and meeting endless “shoulds”, crowding out desire, fun and genuine choice.
- ShiftGrit’s approach targets and weakens limiting beliefs using counter-conditioning, freeing up mental and emotional capacity for values-based decisions.
- As limiting beliefs ease, people begin setting boundaries, saying no, editing their commitments and gradually adding back hobbies, play and relationships that actually feel good.
“People say, ‘Nothing’s really that bad, but nothing’s really good either. I’m just on autopilot, calling it functioning.’”
What drives someone to seek a life that’s more than a constant “five out of ten”? This episode of The Shift Show digs into that flat, going-through-the-motions feeling so many people quietly call “functioning”, even while everything feels a bit numb. Registered psychologist and ShiftGrit founder Andrea McTague teams up with psychology student and client experience team member Kai Ongaro to talk about living on autopilot.
Andrea describes it as “moving through life mechanically… a solid five out of ten mood constantly”, where work, parenting, relationships and social life all get done, but with “a lack of joy or passion, sometimes a lack of purpose”. You’ll hear how this high-functioning numbness often springs from chronic, layered stress rather than a single big trauma.
They break down how limiting beliefs like “I’m irresponsible”, “I’m worthless”, “I’m not good enough” or “I’m not in control” push people into over-functioning, perfectionism and people-pleasing, leaving no space for fun, rest or genuine desire. Andrea calls this the “walnut brain” – the threat system that keeps you focused on avoiding pain instead of seeking joy.
The conversation stays practical, showing how therapy at ShiftGrit targets those limiting beliefs at their roots, using counter-conditioning to “blast them out” so people can stop living by “shoulds” and start making choices based on values and wants. As those beliefs loosen, clients gradually start saying no, setting boundaries, editing out draining obligations and then adding back hobbies, play and connection that actually “fill your cup”.
Expect everyday examples of autopilot in sex lives that feel like chores, friendships that thin out, and parents who “don’t even know what’s fun anymore” — along with simple checks, like noticing that physical “ugh” that signals your walnut brain is steering the ship. If your life technically works but feels stuck on meh, could it be time to loosen your grip, zoom out, and ask what might actually feel good again?
Do you want to link to this podcast?
Get the buttons here!
More From This Show
The latest episodes from the same podcast.