E278: The Disease Model Doesn’t Let Me Off the HookE278: The Disease Model Doesn’t Let Me Off the Hook
Sober Friends
Matt and Steve question whether the disease model of alcoholism is an excuse or a helpful explanation, sharing how it intersects with responsibility, shame and long-term sobriety. Their conversation also looks at the role of AA, fellowship and memory in staying alcohol-free over the years.
36:23•2 Jun 2026
Does Calling Alcoholism a Disease Let You Off the Hook?
Episode Overview
- Seeing alcoholism as a disease can reduce shame but does not remove personal responsibility for staying sober.
- After achieving sobriety, choosing to drink again is framed as a decision, not an uncontrollable event from nowhere.
- AA’s strength is often in its fellowship and support network, which can improve long‑term outcomes for those who engage with it.
- The idea of a ‘built‑in forgetter’ explains why people minimise past drinking harm and benefit from ongoing connection.
- Comparisons with conditions like diabetes and obesity highlight that different people’s brains and bodies respond very differently to alcohol.
““Now that you know the why, there’s something you can do about it.””
What drives someone to seek a life without alcohol? This candid chat between Matt and Steve on Sober Friends gets right into that question by tackling the “disease model” of alcoholism head-on. Prompted by a Charlie Sheen clip criticising AA’s disease view as a “no-fault” excuse, they unpack why that take doesn’t match their experience.
Steve points out that, early on, seeing alcoholism as a disease can explain the chaos, but once sober, “then it is a choice… then you do take personal responsibility of whether you want to pick up a drink or not.” So there’s no free pass here – just a framework that helps people stop calling themselves weak or broken.
Matt shares how his relationship with food and GLP‑1 medication mirrors his drinking: something in his brain felt “weeble wobbly” and out of place, making him eat and drink in ways he didn’t actually want. For him, the disease idea isn’t about blaming biology; it’s a way of saying, “Now that you know the why, there’s something you can do about it.” They also talk about why long-term AA members keep going to meetings instead of “getting better and leaving”.
It’s partly about passing on experience to newcomers, and partly about that infamous “built‑in forgetter” that makes past misery look not so bad. Steve admits he still needs meetings, even at nearly 16 years sober, because he forgets where drinking really took him.
Along the way, they touch on genetics, comparisons with diabetes and obesity, the comfort of fellowship, and what it’s like to hike, go to ball games, and live a full life without alcohol at the centre of everything. If you’ve ever wondered whether calling alcoholism a disease lets you off the hook, this conversation might get you thinking about a different question: what if it actually helps you stay on it?
Do you want to link to this podcast?
Get the buttons here!
More From This Show
The latest episodes from the same podcast.
Related Episodes
Similar episodes from other shows in the catalogue.