Whats AA, Whats Not and Why it MattersWhats AA, Whats Not and Why it Matters
Alcoholics Alive!
Shank and Wayne close out their season by sorting what truly belongs to Alcoholics Anonymous and what comes from wider recovery culture. They reflect on service, meetings, old-timers, and the importance of keeping AA simple and spiritual for alcoholics who still suffer.
39:56•11 Aug 2026
Whats AA, Whats Not and Why It Matters
Episode Overview
- Intensive work with other alcoholics is presented as a key protection against drinking and a practical way to live better.
- Keeping AA focused on its spiritual programme and Big Book instructions is stressed as more effective than broad recovery culture.
- Meeting attendance alone is described as insufficient; the programme lies in the steps and traditions, not just showing up.
- Old-timers with long sobriety are seen as vital sources of experience and direction, not as people who should fade into the background.
- Labelled recovery meetings in facilities can confuse people about AA, so the hosts argue for clear AA meetings or honest alternatives.
“Practical experience shows that nothing will so much ensure immunity from drinking as intensive work with other alcoholics.”
How do people cope with the challenges of staying sober? This season wrap-up of *Alcoholics Alive!* pulls together fifteen episodes of debate, humour, and hard-earned experience into one straight-talking conversation about what is AA, what isn’t, and why that difference really matters. You’ll hear Shank and Wayne keep returning to a simple anchor: the Big Book and a spiritual programme of action.
They read from page 89 – “nothing will so much ensure immunity from drinking as intensive work with other alcoholics” – and build from there, stressing that service to other alcoholics is “an absolute recipe for success just in life”. For them, being “recovered members of Alcoholics Anonymous” is about action, not slogans. The episode takes aim at recovery buzzwords and culture that have crept into AA.
Shank laughs about being “weirdly obsessed” with labels like felon, while Wayne questions the phrase “I’m in recovery”, saying it can feel like being “constantly analysing and trying to fix something that doesn’t need to be fixed”. They contrast that with the clarity of identifying as “a recovered alcoholic” living a spiritual way of life. A big chunk of the chat focuses on meetings versus the programme.
They argue that meetings alone can give the illusion of doing AA, while the actual programme sits in the steps and traditions, carried one alcoholic to another. Recovery-style meetings in treatment centres are called out as “recovery meetings and not meetings of Alcoholics Anonymous”, and they suggest that if a facility can’t host a genuine AA meeting, it might be better not to badge it as AA at all. Old-timers get an enthusiastic defence, too.
Far from being something to fear, Shank and Wayne reckon AA needs more visible long-sober members giving practical direction, not fewer. If you’re curious about how AA can stay simple, spiritual, and effective amid modern recovery trends, this season wrap-up is worth your time. What parts of your own sobriety might be more fantasy than action?
Do you want to link to this podcast?
Get the buttons here!
More From This Show
The latest episodes from the same podcast.