Candy, Sugar, and Cravings with Guest Molly CarmelCandy, Sugar, and Cravings with Guest Molly Carmel
The Recovered Life Show
Host Damon Frank talks with therapist and author Molly Carmel about how sugar addiction can quietly replace alcohol and drugs in recovery. Their conversation centres on holiday triggers, ultra-processed foods, and creating a more realistic, kinder relationship with food instead of staying stuck in the diet-and-relapse loop.
36:27•31 Oct 2026
Candy, Sugar and Cravings: Molly Carmel on the Addiction Few Take Seriously
Episode Overview
- Sugar can easily replace alcohol and drugs in recovery, creating a new addiction that feels safer but still blocks real freedom.
- Modern ultra-processed foods are designed to be highly addictive and affect mood, thinking, and decision-making.
- Holiday periods like Halloween, Thanksgiving and Christmas often trigger relapse through deeply ingrained food and sugar rituals.
- Diet-style, perfectionist approaches to quitting sugar tend to fuel shame and bingeing; a more flexible, harm-reduction mindset is more sustainable.
- Building a compassionate, long-term relationship with food and with oneself is key to stopping the endless cycle of starting over.
“People who have a problem with you not eating sugar on Halloween, they have the problem. Not you.”
What drives someone to seek a life without alcohol and then realise sugar has quietly taken its place? This Halloween-themed conversation on The Recovered Life Show zeroes in on exactly that, as addictions and eating-disorder therapist Molly Carmel joins host Damon Frank to talk about the "addiction nobody takes seriously": sugar. You'll hear Molly describe herself as a "hardcore sugar addict" who nearly died from food addiction, even after bariatric surgery and while working as an eating-disorders therapist.
Her turning point came when she cut out sugar and flour, went through intense detox, and watched her cravings vanish – a moment that pushed her to rethink everything she’d been taught about weight, food, and recovery. Damon shares his own long history with sugar, from teenage overdosing on sweets to seeing men in rehab make reckless choices after living on giant soft drinks, crisps, and sweets from the local shop.
Together, they highlight how ultra-processed sugar today is "not your grandma's sugar" and how food companies design products to keep people hooked from childhood. The episode digs into the emotional and spiritual side of food addiction: the "Bermuda Triangle" of Halloween, Thanksgiving, and Christmas, the way sugar is woven into 12-step recovery culture, and why many people feel stuck in an endless cycle of diet, shame, binge, and starting over.
Molly talks about her "Stop Starting Over System" and her book *Breaking Up with Sugar*, stressing that freedom comes from building a gentler, more realistic relationship with food rather than chasing perfection. If you're sober from alcohol but knee-deep in doughnuts, Halloween sweets, and fizzy drinks, this conversation might have you asking a tough but important question: how free do you really want to be?
Do you want to link to this podcast?
Get the buttons here!
More From This Show
The latest episodes from the same podcast.