Matt J
Matt J
E250: The Straw Man Chapter of the Big Book
E250: The Straw Man Chapter of the Big Book
E250: The Straw Man Chapter of the Big Book
Tuesday 28th October 2025
Matt and Steve critically examine 'We Agnostics' from the AA Big Book, questioning Bill W.'s logic and exploring faith in recovery.
Explicit
35 minutes
Informative
Honest
Engaging
Inspiring
Thought-provoking
About this podcast
Author:
Matt J
Overview:
Categories:
Sobriety Toolkit
Financial Health in Recovery
Creative Recovery Journeys
Navigating Challenges in Recovery
Navigating Intimate Relationships
Links:
Visit site
Episodes:
270 (View all)
Do you want to link to this podcast?
Get the buttons here!Rethinking 'We Agnostics': A Critical Look at AA's Big Book
Episode Overview
- Questioning Bill W.'s logic in 'We Agnostics' chapter.
- Exploring the balance between intent and accuracy in AA teachings.
- Reflecting on personal faith and spirituality in recovery.
- Embracing kindness and service as forms of spirituality.
- Encouraging open-mindedness and questioning traditional narratives.
If I could stay sober by myself, I wouldn't go to meetings.
Ever wondered what it takes to dissect the complexities of the AA Big Book? Join Matt and Steve in this riveting episode as they take a critical look at the chapter 'We Agnostics.' Matt openly shares his growing frustration with Bill W.'s logic, questioning whether metaphors comparing God to electricity are truly inspired or merely sales tactics. The duo dives into where Bill's arguments may falter and ponder the idea that intent might outweigh accuracy.
The conversation doesn't shy away from addressing how Bill's embellishments and parables, although sometimes misleading, were aimed at helping alcoholics find sobriety. The hosts reflect on their personal journeys, acknowledging the power of AA's singleness of purpose: achieving sobriety and aiding others in their recovery. They explore how the Big Book's teachings can sometimes be taken too literally by members, sparking lively debates.
Listeners are treated to an honest discussion about faith, spirituality, and the role of a higher power in recovery. Matt and Steve candidly express their admiration for those with strong faith while embracing their own agnostic views. Through humour and introspection, they reveal how they find spirituality in everyday kindness and service to others. This episode is a refreshing take on sobriety, encouraging listeners to question, reflect, and ultimately find their own path to recovery.
So, what are your thoughts on Bill W.'s approach? Could intent truly be more important than accuracy?