Demands Versus PreferencesDemands Versus Preferences
Emotional Sobriety: The Next Step in Recovery
Thom’s Nutshell: If you measure your well being according to how others treat you, you are choosing a life over which you have no control. This is voluntary victimization. Allen brings in his study of a “reflective sense of self” as we discuss the ways our difficulties with emotional sobriety impact those we love. Thom and Joe re-explore stoicism through the lens of emotional dependency. Our fear of life is really a fear of emotions. Patrick reads a passage from Adult Children of Emotionally Immature Parents: How to Heal from Distant, Rejecting, or Self-Involved Parents by Lindsay Gibson. Our music is provided by the great southern artist Jefferson Ross. Learn more about Jefferson at jeffersonross.com Visit our website: www.emotionalsobriety.info Learn more about Joe C., Secular AA and Rebellion Dogs here: https://rebelliondogspublishing.com Follow us on social media: Instagram: thomrutledge2 Joe C. Twitter: @Rebellion_Dogs Friendly Circle Berlin workshops: https://friendlycircleberlin.org/events Allen’s book, 12 Essential Insights for Emotional Sobriety: https://www.amazon.com/12-Essential-Insights-Emotional-Sobriety/dp/1955415129/ Join Allen & Thom at our Thursday night, 7pm PST Zoom meeting on Emotional Sobriety and the Steps (login information below): https://zoom.us/j/330149513 Password: 375986 For our ongoing workshop video series on Emotional Sobriety and the 12 Steps, visit our YouTube channel here: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCHEM2-kqLkfp3I4c0jy-X-g Also, please join our “Emotional Sobriety and Recovery” FB Group at the following link: https://www.facebook.com/groups/120450976662519 We’d love to stay in touch in between meetings. We appreciate feedback! Contact Patrick, our producer, at pndirective4@gmail.com for any questions or comments.
27:44•21 Jul 2026
Demands, Preferences and Emotional Sobriety: Stop Measuring Yourself by Others
Episode Overview
- Measuring well-being by how others treat you leads to "voluntary victimization" and loss of control over your life.
- Shifting from demands to preferences helps right-size conflicts and reduces emotional drama.
- A "reflected sense of self" begins in childhood and can grow into unhealthy dependence on others’ approval.
- Emotional dependency is part of human development, but there is a new possibility of becoming more self-supporting.
- Emotional loneliness linked to emotionally immature parenting can continue into adulthood without conscious self-awareness and change.
“If you measure your well-being according to how others treat you, you are choosing a life over which you have no control. This is voluntary victimization.”
What drives someone to seek a life without alcohol? This conversation on Emotional Sobriety: The Next Step in Recovery tackles that question by looking closely at how our emotional lives can keep us stuck in old patterns. Psychotherapists and authors Allen Berger and Thom Rutledge, joined by Joe and Patrick, talk about the difference between demands and preferences in everyday life.
Thom offers a striking reminder: "If you measure your well-being according to how others treat you, you are choosing a life over which you have no control. This is voluntary victimization." From there, they unpack how chasing approval and letting others define our worth feeds emotional dependency. Allen brings in his idea of a "reflected sense of self"—the way we learn, from childhood onward, to see ourselves through other people’s eyes.
You’ll hear how this can evolve into a constant worry about being liked, accepted or lovable, and how that pattern shows up in addiction and recovery alike. Joe shares how he used to "desperately" need approval, but now treats approval as a preference rather than a condition for feeling okay. The group also link emotional sobriety with stoicism, joking about "losing your marbles" while using metaphors and stories from therapy rooms and recovery conferences.
They stress that emotional dependency isn’t a sign you’re broken; it’s part of human development, and there’s "a new possibility" where you can move beyond needing the environment to validate you. Patrick reads from Lindsay Gibson’s book on emotionally immature parents, highlighting "emotional loneliness" and the pain of feeling unseen as a child.
The hosts connect this to the fear of emotions many people have in recovery—captured in the line, "The fear of life is really the fear of emotions." If you’ve ever felt your mood rise and fall with other people’s opinions, this episode offers food for thought on how emotional sobriety might help you stand on your own two feet. How much of your well-being is still on loan to others?
Do you want to link to this podcast?
Get the buttons here!
More From This Show
The latest episodes from the same podcast.