Can We Be Actively Indifferent?Can We Be Actively Indifferent?
Emotional Sobriety: The Next Step in Recovery
Thom’s Nutshell: The ability to speak several languages is an asset, but the ability to keep your mouth shut in any language is priceless. Seeking truth through withholding judgment. What makes it difficult to keep our mouths shut. The Odyssey, grades in school, “won’t” drink versus “can’t” drink. What is the suffering that breaks us open and makes us susceptible to change? Our music is provided by the great southern artist Jefferson Ross. Learn more about Jefferson at jeffersonross.com Visit our website: www.emotionalsobriety.info Learn more about Joe C., Secular AA and Rebellion Dogs here: https://rebelliondogspublishing.com Follow us on social media: Instagram: thomrutledge2 Joe C. Twitter: @Rebellion_Dogs Friendly Circle Berlin workshops: https://friendlycircleberlin.org/events Allen’s book, 12 Essential Insights for Emotional Sobriety: https://www.amazon.com/12-Essential-Insights-Emotional-Sobriety/dp/1955415129/ Join Allen & Thom at our Thursday night, 7pm PST Zoom meeting on Emotional Sobriety and the Steps (login information below): https://zoom.us/j/330149513 Password: 375986 For our ongoing workshop video series on Emotional Sobriety and the 12 Steps, visit our YouTube channel here: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCHEM2-kqLkfp3I4c0jy-X-g Also, please join our “Emotional Sobriety and Recovery” FB Group at the following link: https://www.facebook.com/groups/120450976662519 We’d love to stay in touch in between meetings. We appreciate feedback! Contact Patrick, our producer, at pndirective4@gmail.com for any questions or comments.
36:34•28 Jul 2026
Active Indifference, Listening and Emotional Sobriety
Episode Overview
- Shifting from "I can’t drink" to "I won’t drink" can move a person from feeling like a victim to recognising personal agency.
- Listening quietly and giving others space to speak is often more helpful than offering constant opinions or advice.
- Suffering can eventually "break something open", making change and recovery possible, but the timing is different for everyone.
- Practising small moments of non-judgment, even for two minutes at a time, can build mental fitness over time.
- Recognising that we create meaning, rather than treating events as inherently good or bad, can reduce defensiveness and divisiveness.
“The ability to speak several languages is an asset, but the ability to keep your mouth shut in any language is priceless.”
How do people find strength in their journey to sobriety? This conversation between Dr Allen Berger, Thom Rutledge and their guest Patrick circles around a surprisingly tricky skill: being quiet, staying open, and becoming "actively indifferent" instead of jumping to judgement.
Early on, Thom shares his nutshell line that sets the tone: "The ability to speak several languages is an asset, but the ability to keep your mouth shut in any language is priceless." From there, you’ll hear stories about over-talking in therapy, a client asking, "Do you think next time I could talk?", and the slow shift from dominating conversations to listening as a genuine act of care.
Patrick talks about recovery through the lens of suffering — how long someone can run on the "hamster wheel" before the pain finally "breaks something open" and change becomes possible. The group contrasts "I can’t drink because I’m an alcoholic" with "I won’t drink", showing how language can move a person out of victim mode and into personal choice.
Joe C.’s Beyond Belief reading on non-judgment sparks a rich discussion about preferences, opinions and the "disease of the mind" that comes from constantly setting what we like against what we dislike. Dr Berger questions whether total non-attachment is even possible, instead focusing on being more open and aware of the meanings we slap onto events and people. Things get very real when they apply these ideas to political divisiveness, including strong reactions to Donald Trump.
Rather than attacking, Allen talks about trying to see that others also love their country but imagine its future differently, and how the real work is reducing the divisiveness inside ourselves. If you’re curious about emotional sobriety, judgment, and the quiet power of listening, this conversation might have you asking: could "active indifference" be the next step in your own recovery?
Do you want to link to this podcast?
Get the buttons here!
More From This Show
The latest episodes from the same podcast.